Ohio Municipal League Legislative Bulletin

OML Home • Affiliates • Classifieds  • Publications  About OML

Join the OML Legislative Bulletin E-Mail List Here

or Text "OMLOHIO" to 22828

March 24, 2017

This week the General Assembly continued to deliberate on the budget while also working on multiple bills. The largest amount of activity this week involved the transportation budget which was passed by the Senate. Meanwhile, municipal income taxes continue to undergo attention from General Assembly members, as extensive testimony was heard again this week on that subject. The League would like to continue to express our gratitude in the dozens of municipal officials who remain highly engaged and productive in talking to members of the General Assembly, both in district and here in Columbus. Your conversations with your members are essential to maintaining local control in Ohio.
Municipal income tax issues were heard repeatedly in two committees on Tuesday and Wednesday this past week. On Tuesday morning, the House Ways and Means committee heard proponent testimony opposing the centralized collection of net profit business filings from Policy Matters Ohio, as well as testimony supporting it from John Green, a business owner in Stow, OH, and the Ohio Manufacturer's Association. For those interested in, testimony presented to the committee can be accessed via the committee's website: http://www.ohiohouse.gov/committee/ways-and-means
Highlights from the hearing include:
That afternoon, the House Finance Subcommittee on State Government and Agency Review had Tax Commissioner Testa return for further questioning on the tax changes proposed in the budget. Submitted testimony can be accessed via the subcommittee's website: http://www.ohiohouse.gov/committee/finance-subcommittee-on-state-government-and-agency-review.

Testa brought information the subcommittee had previously requested. Rep. Faber (R-Celina) then asked Testa to help him draft "response letters" to constituents writing his office asking he oppose centralized collection. Highlights include:
On Wednesday morning, the House Ways and Means committee heard proponent testimony on the municipal income tax portions of the budget bill from Jack Kostak, a business owner, Angela Radic, a tax accountant and Scott Williams from the Ohio Society of Realtors, who was accompanied by Tom Zaino of Zaino Hall & Farrin LLC. Melinda Frank also gave her testimony from the previous afternoon. Highlights include:
The House Ways and Means hearings on HB 49 have officially concluded. The House Finance Committee will begin hearings on the bill next week.
Last week, the National League of Cities (NLC) held its annual Congressional Cities Conference in Washing ton D.C. which was attended by over 600 municipal officials from across the state including OML Executive Director Kent Scarrett, league legal Counsel Garry Hunter and nearly 70 municipal officials from the Buckeye state.
The five-day event was an opportunity for league staff and municipal officials to learn more about issues impacting municipalities on the local, state and federal level while dedicating one day for meeting members of Congress on the Hill and pressing issues important to local communities. The congressional meetings were also a wonderful opportunity to educate members of congress on issues been presented in President Trump's first budget proposal impacting cities and villages.
The league appreciates the meetings that we participated in with members of Ohio's delegation that included visits with Senator Rob Portman, Reps. Bob Gibbs, Joyce Beatty and Warren Davidson. We appreciate the time afforded our visits and the interesting dialogue surrounding many municipal issues.    
The unveiling of President Trump's Federal budget proposal a mixture of good and bad for Ohio's communities. The budget revealed cuts amounting to billions of dollars from domestic program funding, as well as increased programs to several vital initiatives that invest in municipalities.
First let's examine the cuts. These programs are vital to ensuring cities across the United States can grow and prosper. These cuts threaten the hard-won progress many local communities have made. We are asking Ohio's municipalities to take a stand against these devastating blows to the vitality and growth of our cities and villages. These Federal dollars fund programs that municipalities simply cannot make up for. They include:
But the Federal budget proposal also allocates funds issues that are crucially important to local communities. These include:
These increased funds indicate an important investment in issues that have too long plagued the most vulnerable in our local communities. On the other hand, the cuts would be a great challenge to the federal-local partnerships that have become a crucial part of investing in and revitalizing our states, local communities, and families.
We urge our members to contact your members of Congress and let them know Ohio municipalities support increased funding for important local issues and stand opposed to cuts in crucial local programs. We believe our local communities are worth the investment. 
We are providing a link to a sample letter, produced by our federal advocates at the National League of Cities (NLC), which league members may want to consider when communicating with their Federal representatives. NLC model action letter is at: http://www.nlc.org/FightTheCuts
OML members may also be interested in these additional resources from NLC which include: NLC Article in response to the budget: https://citiesspeak.org/2017/03/17/city-leaders-will-fight-the-cuts-because-cities-are-worth-fighting-for/ and NLC President Matt Zone article in The Hill Magazine: http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/economy-budget/324775-congress-its-time-to-fight-for-cities.
The General Assembly is readying HB 26 the Transportation Budget for conference committee. A conference committee occurs when the House Speaker and Senate President choose to create one, after both chambers have passed the same bill with different language. The Senate passed their version of the Transportation Budget on Wednesday afternoon after the Senate Transportation, Commerce and Workforce Committee passed the bill that morning.
Before voting, Committee Chairman Frank LaRose (R-Copley) offered and the Committee accepted a substantial omnibus amendment. LaRose stated that he had three goals in this budget: to invest in and maintain the state's existing transportation infrastructure, to invest in public transportation, and to provide local governments with additional funding for roads and bridges.
Highlights of the omnibus amendment impactful to municipalities include provisions that:
The League would like to thank the many people who continue to work hard to put this budget together. Overall, we are happy that funds are being increased for local transportation. However, we are still disappointed that only counties are allowed to assess additional license plate fees under this budget. Municipalities and townships should also be allowed to levy this fee, or at least have some mechanism, to help fill the desperate need for local transportation dollars.
The Transportation Budget must be passed 90 days prior to July 1-which is March 30th. Senate President Larry Obhof  (R-Medina) announced his intention to convene conference committee on March 27 while the Speaker has not commented on the date as of this writing.
Senate Transportation Budget Documents:
Full Comparison Document HERE
Summary of Senate Changes HERE
LSC analysis HERE
This week, the Medical Marijuana Control Program released a number of proposed rules to the Joint Committee on Agency Rule Review. Municipalities across the state have expressed great concern about the uncertainties surrounding the medical marijuana laws in Ohio. These initial proposals can be viewed here: http://www.medicalmarijuana.ohio.gov/rules
On May 5 in Hilliard, Ohio, the Ohio Association of Public Safety Directors, a League affiliate organization, will be hosting officials from the Ohio Department of Commerce and the Ohio Pharmacy Board to discuss the new rules and expectations for the future.  Details on this conference are available by emailing: jbrown@omlohio.org .
Nearly 80 Ohio municipalities have filed lawsuits against the State of Ohio over a wireless equipment law which was passed during the lame duck session of the General Assembly last year. Companies such as AT&T made significant promises to legislators that passing this legislation would usher in new jobs and network modernization. However, the legislature decided to move the legislation extremely quickly and attached it to SB 331, which contained multiple subjects. The League, along with other interested parties, has been working to clarify what the legislation's effects will be and what to expect going forward.
Meanwhile, the courts will decide the fate of the original legislation. The legislation likely infringes on municipalities' constitutional Home Rule authority and likely violates the "single subject rule" which requires that all Ohio legislation (other than appropriations) address a single subject.

To offer an example of the complaints filed, we are attaching the City of Cleveland's complaint HERE.
This week, the House State and Local Government Committee heard testimony on HB 69, which would require reimbursement of certain township fire and emergency medical service levy revenue forgone because of the creation of a municipal tax increment financing district. The bill was introduced by Representative Bob Cupp (R-Lima). We have provided a link to the sponsor's testimony HERE. Testimony that has been presented to the House State and Local Government Committee on this subject in addition to access to the bill's text, legislative analysis and fiscal impact statement is available on the committee's website at: http://www.ohiohouse.gov/committee/state-and-local-government.
The League has not taken a position on the bill but does have some comments. First, to the extent that this adds another exemption from TIF financing, it has the potential to reduce the efficacy of a TIF. Concerns have been expressed that this proposal could make TIF's a less attractive economic development incentive. Secondly, there is concern that the proposal gives townships a stronger negotiating position in the process of creating TIF's, because the Township has a choice whether to accept or refuse the reimbursement; i.e., it gives them another chip to bargain with.
Generally, we are not sure how significant this is in isolation. However, it is part of a disturbing trend where the state gives certain preferences to empower townships over municipalities, despite the fact that municipalities are the primary public engine of economic development.
All of the bill's discussed can be accessed, including analysis and fiscal impact statements via the Ohio Legislative Service Commission's (LSC) website: http://www.lsc.ohio.gov.
Several bills received actions this week that effect municipalities. First, SB 37, introduced by Senator Cliff Hite (R-Findlay), which would require the Ohio Peace Officer Training Commission to develop and conduct a chief of police training course for newly appointed village, city, and township chiefs of police, was passed unanimously out of the Senate this week. The League did not submit testimony on the bill but asked for some amendments that were not adopted.
Next, the Committee heard testimony on HB 34, introduced by Representatives Steve Hambley (R-Brunswick) and Scott Ryan (R-Newark) which would authorize certain state agencies, local governments, and other boards, commissions, and officers to deliver certain notices by ordinary mail and electronically instead of by certified mail. The Committee took testimony from Shelley Davis, Administrator of the Cuyahoga County Board of Revision, who said the bill could save her agency a large amount of money.
Next, the House State and Local Government Committee heard sponsor testimony on HB 121, which was introduced by Representative Jay Edwards (R-Nelsonville) and would require a public authority to consider all piping materials that meet the engineering specifications for a state-funded water or waste water project. The League opposes the bill because it would forbid municipalities from passing ordinances that exclude PVC piping from bidding in these types of RFP's.
Lastly, the Senate Local Government, Public Safety and Veterans Affairs Committee heard sponsor testimony on SB 60, which was introduced by Senators Michael Skindell (D-Lakewood) and Kris Jordan (R-Ostrander) and would regulate the use of drones for gathering evidence and information by law enforcement officers in Ohio. Skindell said, "The legislation states that, with rare exceptions, law enforcement must obtain search warrants ... based on probable cause... The bill outlines rare instances where drones may be used without obtaining a warrant (emergency situations), and details the post-search application process necessary in these situations. It also provides other limited situations where drones may be used to collect information such as traffic accidents and aiding in locating missing persons whose health or mental state creates the need for such use. Finally, the legislation also provides stringent annual reporting requirements regarding drone use by law enforcement agencies, judges and the
attorney general."
The Workers Compensation Budget HB 27, introduced by Representative Tom Brinkman (R-Mt. Lookout), received a hearing this week in the House Insurance Committee. Proponent testimony was offered to promote a provision that would allow "mental-mental" claims for cases of PTSD claims among first responders. The proposal (presumably) would change a century-old precedent that a physical injury must accompany any mental claims (i.e., physical-mental), as workers compensation exists to cover only work-related injuries.
Testimony of this nature was given by the Ohio Association for Justice (OAJ) (an association of trial lawyers), the Ohio Psychiatric Physicians Association, and the Fraternal Order of Police. Also, Speaker Cliff Rosenberg (R-Clarksville) was quoted as saying such a provision could proceed as an amendment in this bill, while Senators Frank LaRose (R-Copley) and Edna Brown (D-Toledo) introduced a bill to this effect yesterday (Thursday).
The League has opposed bills to this effect in the past for a several reasons and continues to be concerned  if such an amendment were added to the budget package. We have not seen the language of the current proposal, but previous proposals of this sort drew members concern due to:
We have not prepared materials related to this specific proposal, but click HERE for our letter on this issue, written when this concept was introduced as SB 5.
The Senate Government Oversight and Reform Committee heard proponent testimony on SB 88. The bill was introduced by Senator Lou Terhar (R-Green Township) and would modify the composition and powers of the financial planning and supervision commission of a political subdivision that is in a state of fiscal emergency and to clarify the duties of that political subdivision. Testifying in support was Ohio State Auditor Dave Yost who largely repeated his testimony on an identical bill in the House on HB 103, which was introduced by Representative Bill Reineke (R-Tiffin).
Yost said "Local governments make up the majority of the commission under current system, which frankly is a problem . . . HB103 brings greater objectivity to the commission." The bill makes a number of changes that would reduce the influence-upon the commission-of the jurisdiction in fiscal emergency.
SB118  PTSD TREATMENT-FIRST RESPONDERS - To make peace officers, firefighters, and emergency medical workers diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder arising from employment without an accompanying physical injury eligible for compensation and benefits under Ohio's Workers' Compensation Law for up to one year and to prohibit such a person from receiving a disability benefit from a state retirement system for post-traumatic stress disorder arising from employment without an accompanying physical injury during the time period the person receives compensation and benefits under the Workers' Compensation Law for the disorder.
Introduced       LaRose, F        Brown, E
HB139 PUBLIC RECORD DISCLOSURE EXEMPTIONS - To eliminate the public disclosure exemption for any permanently retained record 100 years after the date of its creation.
Introduced       Perales, R         Keller, C
SB103  COUNTY EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS - To permit a board of county commissioners, as an alternative to entering into an agreement to establish a countywide emergency management agency, to enter into a contract of not longer than four years with the county sheriff or a chief of a fire department that has countywide authority to implement a countywide emergency management program.
Introduced       Coley, W

Committee Schedule

Past Bulletins: